Are you frugal or cheap?

This post was written by elisa cundiff, outreach coordinator on January 15, 2009
Posted Under: Cheap Living Tips

For some people, being “frugal” is just a euphemism for being cheap. So, what is the difference? And where do you draw the line?  Silicon Valley Blogger got us thinking about the effects of extreme saving.

Which of the following are you willing to do?

  • Cut your own hair?
  • Ration milk in your house?
  • Recycle and collect money for all of your cans?
  • Purchase only used furniture, electronics and clothing?
  • Only order water when you go out to eat with friends and family?
  • Always make your own lunch?
  • Purchase all of your groceries at Sam’s Club or Costco?
  • Steal napkins, ketchup, salt, pepper and other condiments from fast food stores?
  • Tip less because it cuts back on the overall bill?
  • Check out movies from your library for free, instead of dropping $10 at the theater.
  • Grow your own food?

For me, reusing, recycling, and buying second-hand furniture allows me to save money, while strengthening my self-image as an environmentally conscious citizen. Taking condiments from fast-food places feels like theft to me and (having worked as a server) I would never think of tipping less than the regional norm.

But I know people who have done all of these things, and more!

So, how do you decide if you’re being cheap or frugal?

You really just have to think about your values, and the cost-effectiveness of your choices.

While small steps can definitely save you big bucks over time, be sure to throw your energy into the changes that will save you the most cash, rather than making large life changes to shave off nugatory amounts here and there.

But the real key is to make meaningful choices that do not undermine your values. And the best possible changes you can make are those that echo your values and also manage to save you money.

  • Great comments @ TSrump,Weakonomist. My answer would have been probably different if I answered this question 9 months ago.
    I'm definitely Frugal, reason being ::Frugal people don’t mind spending money, they just don’t like wasting it…and they think its a good idea to try your best to live within your means. They know that saving money and investing it is the key to a steadily improving lifestyle. They are creative in finding ways to enjoy life that don’t cost a lot of money. They set financial goals and work to achieve them, whether its sending the kids through college or saving for that trip around the world. They make purchases based on the true worth of what they’re buying, not on status or hype. Thanks for raising such a topic.
  • TStrump
    The one thing I do is cut my own hair.
    I shave my head every few days.
    I've saved hundreds over the past 4 years!
  • Karl
    I am so sick of the "20%" rule! Isn't tipping supposed to be for good service?

    So why should I be forced to feel "cheap" if I tip 5% for really crappy service?
  • No offense to the food service industry, but I've basically stopped going to restaurants where I have to tip. Between Moe's, Panera, and Subway me and The Sheconomist just don't have much need to spend more than $7 each on food.

    Can't give up IHOP though. MMMM IHOP, now I know what we're doing tonight.
  • Sarah
    As a previous waitress, I think people who can't afford a tip shouldn't be eating out.
  • I'm working on a post right now where I talk about hating the word "frugal." Thought I prefer the term "thrifty" I am in fact quite cheap.

    I have frugal tendencies, I haven't paid for a haircut in years and I take my lunch every day.

    I say frugal people are trying to save money, cheap people just don't want to spend it. I make enough that I can toss around a few bucks, I just don't like to spend it.
  • Cheap&Proud
    Cheap or Frugal? I'm CHEAP and proud of it.

    It's taken me a full year to really slash my spending habits but now I think about every single thing that I buy and I feel more in control of my life.

    When you're spending on things that you "need" you're really just letting your money control you.
  • Lucia
    Ha! This list is far too familiar!

    One "big change" that I made was moving into a lower-rent building. The move was a hassle (moving always is) but it was one of the most cost-effective decisions that I made in terms of living within my means and I will save thousands of dollars this year!
blog comments powered by Disqus

© 2009 LendingTree, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Call Thrive at 1.888.831.4080